Jane Rizzoli and Maura Isles
Thursday, August 19th, 2010Well, it’s been a long time since I read these books, but the new tv show on TNT whet my appetite for comparison. As always the books are far superior. The appealing aspect of the show is the humor. Maura Isles is funny. She reminds me of Temperance Brennan on “Bones.” Both gals are so intelligent that they can’t relate to the average person, and come out with comments that make me smile.
I am rereading the whole series and am now on “The Sinner.” The books are so much more serious and lack the “hometown” Boston flavor of the television program. Jane Rizzoli has a unique relationship with her mother and needs to prove herself. Her mother seems to prefer the boys in the family, which is true in some families, unfortunately. She may be attractive, but she is not the knock-out beauty Angie Harmon is. Maura Isles is not even introduced until the second book, and in the first book, Jane has a smaller part than she will later on.
The books are completely engaging and page-turners. The television program has a different tone, even the theme song sounds upbeat. Both the books and the television shows are winners, I just prefer the books!











